Back To School Pencil Cookies

Sugar Cookies in the shape of pencils with chocolate tip, fruit rollup as erasers and aluminum foil as binding
Getting ready for kids to go back to school?  If your child is a bit anxious, why not set up a Back To School Party and invite a few friends or new classmates? Use the versatile sugar cookie recipe to make Back To School Pencil Cookies to go with other delicious school-themed treats to make the party fun and lighthearted.

Theme Parties and Birthday Party line divider

Sugar Cookies Dough : Ingredients

  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 1/2 tsp baking powder
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 6 tbs (3/4 stick) unsalted butter, softened
  • 1/3 cup (1/3 stick) shortening
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 tbs whole milk
  • 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
  • Any optional flavorings if desired, like lemon-lime, cinnamon or anise.

Pencil Cookies Decorations : Ingredients

  • 1 block of semi-sweet chocolate
  • Several red Fruit Roll-Ups in strips
  • Aluminum Foil cut into long thin strips and folded over

Theme Parties and Birthday Party line divider

Sugar Cookies Dough : Directions

blank line divider
Sugar Cookies - Supplies
blank line divider

Step 1. Supplies needed for the sugar cookies: flour, baking powder, salt, butter, shortening, sugar, egg, milk, vanilla extract and any other optional flavorings.

Step 2 to Step 11. Follow same directions for Basic Sugar Cookie Dough Recipe.

Pencil Cookie Cutouts: To make pencil cut outs, use a sharp knife to cut out strips of dough size approx 4″ x  1″.  Use the knife to cut out the corners on one end of the strip.  This is the pencil tip.

blank  line divider
blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - Baking them
blank  line divider

Step 12. Bake cookies in the middle of oven rack for about 8 to 10 minutes on 375 F. Bake until edges are light brown. Take out of the oven and let cool on wire rack.

Once cooled, cover the body with yellow Royal icing.  Place on a wire rack.  Let dry and harden.

blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - Decorate with icing and embellishments
blank  line divider

Step 13. Roll out strips of red Fruit Roll-Ups and cut into 3″ strips.  Wrap the rectangle end in the Fruit Roll-Up.  This will be the eraser side.

blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - Dip tip in melted chocolate
blank  line divider

Step 14. Melt some chocolate in the microwave on low for a few seconds and stir.  Continue microwaving in intervals and keep stirring until it is melted. Dip the pointed side of the cookie pencil into the chocolate.  This end is the pencil tip.blank line divider

Back To School Pencil Cookies - make erasers using Fruit Roll Ups
blank line divider

Step 15. Let the pencils dry on a sheet of wax or parchment paper.

blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - add aluminum foil for the rim
blank  line divider

Step 16. Once the chocolate tips have dried, fold strips of aluminum foil and wrap around the end of the pencil, covering the edge of the Fruit Roll-Up.

blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - ready for the party
blank  line divider

Step 17. For the Back To School Party decorations, decorate the table with school supplies, agenda books, rulers, bright colored paper and party supplies, etc. Spread a few cookies out on the table and place them next to the rulers.  Your guests will do a double take as they enter the room!

blank line divider
Back To School Pencil Cookies - close up shot of the cookies on the party table
blank  line divider

Step 18. These pencils will be a hit at your party and for once, it’s OK to bite the ends of your pencil and to chew it!  Enjoy!

blank line divider

Other Back To School Theme Ideas

Back to Top ↑

blank line divider

Comments Closed